Simon Leasher's Film Blog
Simon Leasher’s Film Blog
HomeNotesArchiveAbout
Sign in

Whalefall (2026) Review: A Nasty Surprise Beneath the Waves

Brian Duffield delivers an uncomfortable survival thriller with some grim imagery

Simon Leasher's avatar
Simon Leasher
Oct 21

Whalefall is a pretty decent thriller that had enough good moments to keep my interest, and it was far better than I was anticipating it to be.

Good Points

  • The setting is horrible.

  • Austin Abrams and Josh Brolin.

  • The visuals get properly weird.

Bad Points

  • The emotional drama doesn’t really work.

  • The balance is slightly off.

  • Some rough edges.

Whalefall Plot

Whalefall is an official adaptation of Daniel Kraus’s bestselling science-fiction thriller novel - A scuba diver who while looking for his father's remains, is swallowed by an 80-foot, 60-ton sperm whale and has just one hour to get out before his oxygen runs out.

Whalefall 2026

My Thoughts on Whalefall

The Setting Is Horrible. In a Good Way

Director Brian Duffield has definitely done a very good job of making this one feel like somewhere you absolutely would not want to be, where it all feels fairly horrifying, but the film thankfully doesn’t rely on that alone, because it also puts in some real effort into making pretty much everything feel pretty disgusting and uncomfortable.

It has this proper sense of physical space running throughout, with the environment playing a massive part, and some of the imagery is pretty grim too, so I wouldn’t blame anyone for feeling a bit queasy during certain moments.

It’s also a film that is not afraid to get weird. It could easily have been yet another fairly ordinary survival thriller, but Duffield has managed to push the visual side of things to become something you don’t really see every week.

Austin Abrams

Abrams is pretty solid, featuring a demanding performance, both physically and emotionally, and he gives it everything here without making it feel like he’s desperately trying to win an acting award.

He makes the uncomfortable moments feel convincing, and there’s also enough vulnerability in the performance to stop the character becoming just another hero who happens to be having a particularly bad day.

Josh Brolin is also good, although I found the emotional side of the film a little less consistent than its survival material - the performances aren’t the problem, as there’s plenty of good work here - but some of the character drama doesn’t come across as well as I am sure was hoped.

The Horror Elements

This isn’t a traditional horror film, and anyone expecting a straightforward creature feature might be surprised by how much time it spends on survival and drama, but that said, there’s enough here to make horror fans get something out of it.

It’s quite a simple approach overall, and most of the tension and horror elements come from the environment of doing such a good job of making you feel uncomfortable.

There are also some properly unpleasant images, and the film doesn’t completely chicken out when it comes to the more gruesome side of things. I wouldn’t call it scary or anything, but it has its moments for sure, and that’s a decent enough result.

The Balance Is Slightly Off

I would say the film doesn’t always balance its different elements particularly well though - the survival scenes are the strongest part for me, while the emotional material slows things down without adding quite as much as it should, where it feels far too keen on explaining its emotional ideas than letting them speak for themselves.

Still, overall the film is doing plenty right - it has a few rough adges but I also wasn’t expecting to enjoy it as much as I did.

A pleasant surprise.

Final Verdict

A more uncomfortable and effective survival thriller than I expected - worth checking out.

More Film Posts:

Insidious: Out of the Further (2026) Review: Better Than Expected, but Still Familiar

Daily Movie Thoughts
·
Oct 17
Insidious: Out of the Further (2026) Review: Better Than Expected, but Still Familiar

Well, it wasn’t as bad as I was anticipating…

Read full story

Other Mommy Review: Rob Savage’s Horror Film Disappoints

Daily Movie Thoughts
·
Oct 14
Other Mommy Review: Rob Savage’s Horror Film Disappoints

Director: Rob Savage

Read full story

Frailty Is So Underrated

Daily Movie Thoughts
·
Oct 7
Frailty Is So Underrated

Frailty, a horror film you will probably rarely see mentioned when people are talking about horror, at least no-where near as much as it should be, even though it has Bill Paxton directing, a great cast and a genuinely uncomfortable idea at its centre, but it still seemingly gets overlooked.

Read full story

Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma (2026) Review

Daily Movie Thoughts
·
Sep 30
Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma (2026) Review

Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma is a very strange horror movie, and also a very personal one.

Read full story

Heart of the Beast Review: Brad Pitt and a Dog Take on the Alaskan Wilderness

Daily Movie Thoughts
·
Sep 27
Heart of the Beast Review: Brad Pitt and a Dog Take on the Alaskan Wilderness

Putting Brad Pitt, a combat dog and the Alaskan wilderness together after a plane crash is a pretty basic yet interesting setup, but the question is whether the movie can turn that into something more than another man-and-dog survival story.

Read full story

Resident Evil (2026) Review: Zach Cregger Finally Gets the Franchise Right

Daily Movie Thoughts
·
Sep 23
Resident Evil (2026) Review: Zach Cregger Finally Gets the Franchise Right

Thank you Mr Cregger.

Read full story
Daily Movie Thoughts
Some daily movie thoughts from a middle aged man who has watched way too many movies, and continues to do so.

Discussion about this post

User's avatar

Keep reading

Simon Leasher’s Film Blog

Some daily movie thoughts from a middle aged man who has watched way too many movies, and continues to do so.

  • About
  • Archive
  • Recommendations
  • Sitemap
© 2026 Simon · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.