Wild Horse Nine Review (2026): Malkovich and Rockwell Are a Match Made in McDonagh Heaven
Martin McDonagh gets John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell together for a very funny trip to Easter Island.
Another McDonagh film where it is quite hard not to laugh…
Good Points
Malkovich and Rockwell’s chemistry and performances.
McDonagh’s trademark mix of dark humor, uncomfortable conversations and unexpected moments.
Easter Island setting.
Strong supporting cast
Bad Points
Dialogue occasionally feels overindulgent.
Some little pacing issues.
Underused political material.
Plot
CIA agents Chris and Lee face a trust-testing mission from Santiago to Easter Island during 1973 in Chile.
My Thoughts on Wild Horse Nine
McDonagh Has Another Pair of Characters I Could Listen to All Day
Martin McDonagh is a director whose films I’ll always make time for, even when I know I’m probably going to spend two hours watching people arguing with each other - In Bruges remains one of my favorites, while Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri and The Banshees of Inisherin showed just how well he can mix dark humor with some sad moments.
Wild Horse Nine has plenty of that familiar McDonagh style, where I expected the dialogue to be a big attraction, and it certainly is.
Malkovich and Rockwell Are a Terrific Combination
John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell are excellent to watch together. Chris and Lee have worked alongside each other for years, and their relationship really comes across in the tiniest moments and exchanges as much as anything.
Rockwell is particularly good as the man who has to put up with Chris’s increasingly unpredictable behavior - Lee often looks as though he’s counting to ten, and Rockwell makes those reactions just as entertaining as the dialogue.
Malkovich gets the more unusual role though, but he makes the most of it - Chris is ill, his memory is becoming unreliable, and he’s started saying things that a man with his history really should keep to himself, and Malkovich plays him with plenty of mischief.
He’s funny, but there’s also sadness in watching him, too.
Easter Island
Easter Island, with its enormous statues and landscape, is quite a fascinating place to put these two men. There’s an almost absurd contrast between the beautiful surroundings and the baggage they’re carrying around with them, no doubt done on purpose.
The island also gives the film some room to breathe visually, rather than relying entirely on just the conversations, which helps to give the film an identity beyond simply feeling like another McDonagh film set somewhere picturesque.
The Political Story
The CIA’s involvement in the events leading up to the coup is an important part of the film as well.
There’s a lot of dark comedy here, as you should expect, but the subject matter is also genuinely ugly, and I did want the film to spend more time exploring the Chilean side of the story though, because the political material is pretty interesting, and I definitely wanted a bit more from this side of things, but obviously I understand why it didn’t take too much of a priority.
I Love Steve Buscemi
Does anyone not love Steve Buscemi? He is a very welcome addition here as MJ, bringing exactly the sort of dry irritation you’d expect, and anything Buscemi is in is a winner for me, well, most of the time.
Parker Posey also makes an impression despite not having as much screen time as I’d have liked, and Tom Waits, Mariana di Girolamo and Ailín Salas do enough too. There’s certainly a lot of acting talent here, and McDonagh is the perfect director for it all to come together.
It Doesn’t Quite Reach the Heights of McDonagh’s Best
The dialogue is obviously still one of McDonagh’s biggest strengths, particularly when the humor can turn uncomfortable without warning, and you either love the kind of writing he brings to the table or you don’t.
I am of course a fan, but here there are some stretches where the film seems a little too pleased with its own verbal sparring, and there are moments when I would have liked things to move along a little quicker.
It’s also difficult not to compare it with In Bruges and The Banshees of Inisherin, both of which I think are stronger films. Still, those are pretty high standards, and there’s more than enough here to make this one a very worthwhile watch.
Final Verdict
A terrific pairing of Malkovich and Rockwell, sharp dialogue and a great setting make Wild Horse Nine another excellent Martin McDonagh film.
More Film Posts:
I Play Rocky Review: A Love Letter to the Making of a Classic
And yes, I got a little sentimental at times.
Never After Dark (2026) Review: Quite Familiar Territory, But Plenty to Enjoy
Stay to the end when watching this film.
Wicker (2026) Review: A Bizarre Little Film With Plenty of Personality
If Olivia Colman is involved in something, I will be watching, as she is always good.
9 Upcoming A24 Movies to Look Out For
A24 have got a bunch of films coming up that I want to see, and there’s some good horror names in the mix too, along with some crime and thriller projects to look out for.
Clayface (2026) Review: Body Horror Meets Superhero Cinema
With director James Watkins at the helm and Tom Rhys Harries leading the cast, Clayface takes a darker approach to the DC universe.
Whalefall (2026) Review: A Nasty Surprise Beneath the Waves
Whalefall is a pretty decent thriller that had enough good moments to keep my interest, and it was far better than I was anticipating it to be.








Discussion about this post